Lila holds a grudge when she re-meets Glenn, her high school nemesis. He’s just moved back to town and got a job at the theater where Lila works, and she wants nothing to do with him. But Glenn claims he’s different now and wants to prove it. When the company has a Secret Santa gift exchange to bring in the Christmas spirit, Glenn swaps assignments to make sure he is Lila’s Secret Santa. Through working together, Lila sees he has changed, but does that mean she can really let go of the past to see him as a friend? And while she struggles with that, she is charmed by the secret Santa gifts she’s been receiving. She will come to a crossroads within herself when she discovers she’s falling in love with the person she used to resent.

Ashlyn is coerced by her stepmother, Miriam, to come join the family on a trip to the Caribbean as part of destination wedding. Miriam is the bride to be, and though Ashlyn has been on her own for a while, her stepfamily is quick to fall into old patterns of undervaluing Ashlyn, putting her down, and expecting her to do everything. To make things harder, Miriam’s fiancé, Bruce, is a wonderful man who is oblivious to Miriam’s ways. Ashlyn finds friendship and the beginnings of love with Bruce’s son, Noah. But Ashlyn struggles to have her own happily ever after when she knows her stepfamily is set to ruin Bruce.

Cali, an up-and-coming famous model, is determined to sprinkle in visits to charitable causes between her Christmas work commitments. To do so, a driver is hired to take her from one city to the next in a week-long trip across the country. Jack, the driver, sees the winter weather is getting worse and suggests a detour at his parents’ home. There Cali finds the peace she’s been seeking. The toll of her profession has made her unhappy, but a glimpse of the family’s joyful life—and one with Jack’s loving heart—might just help her reach her most important dreams.

Nicole, a successful travel blogger, meets Kade, a marketing rep for a travel publishing company, and they form the beginnings of a relationship while exploring an island destination. They juggle their work traveling around the world while seeing each other again. Both know there’s something special between them, but it will be put to the test when Kade’s competitive boss challenges Kade to thwart Nicole’s business.

Hope and Jeb are touring the Ephesus ancient ruins but then are left behind by their tour bus. They must help each other get back to Istanbul. Along the way, Hope draws closer to the memory of a dear loved one, while Jeb fears for his career that's waiting back home. Their journey will help put in perspective what they want in life and their feelings for each other.

Scuba diver Brielle Wilson has always believed the ocean floor is full of treasures just waiting to be found. Over the years she has found rings, coins, lost jewelry and more. Instead of profiting from them, she loves reuniting people with their lost valuables. When she finds a class ring and returns it to Marcus, a handsome US Navy serviceman, Brielle soon discovers what has been missing in her life -- treasures of the heart.