Everything is perfect in Ali’s life until a fortune teller tells her she’ll lose her job, be forced to move apartments, and find true love with a man named John. Ali can’t ignore it after the first two fortunes come true. Her dear friends help find all the men named John that they can, but Ali finds herself drawn to a charming paramedic fireman. But since his name isn’t John, Ali struggles to accept her “future” when her heart yearns for the paramedic.